I’m not quite sure how I fee about this. You can usually count on the People’s Republik Of California to go Full Moonbat, to overdo everything. But, does this make sense or is it moonbat?
California suit against OpenAI could be a roadmap for other states
California’s lawsuit against OpenAI may provide a model for how other states can begin using their law enforcement powers to indirectly regulate the artificial intelligence industry.
Multiple incidents in which autonomous AI agents have hacked computer systems of third party organizations have left critics wrestling with questions about how to respond to the unauthorized infiltration, given that there was little to no direct human involvement.
Legal experts said a first-of-its-kind suit filed by California Attorney General Rob Bonta on Monday is an indication that states may be able to succeed, or at least make progress, where private organizations haven’t, and that the specifics of his claims may provide a roadmap for other attorneys general.
Bonta alleged in the suit that OpenAI violated California’s laws against unfair or deceptive business practices, as well as public nuisance statutes, when the company’s technology went rogue and hacked Hugging Face earlier this year.
An AI company hacking another AI company, and almost nothing bad happened, except HF had to rebuild about a third of their infrastructure. If HF is so upset they could have sued OpenAI, or filed charges. This seems more like the Government simply wants to go after a private company because they can. The first paragraph lays it out: “indirectly regulate the AI industry”
OpenAI has said that the suit “appears to single out” the company for a challenge common among the major AI labs, and noted that it has ““undertaken an extensive and transparent effort to understand and address” how the Hugging Face incident happened.
“California’s lawsuit marks a watershed moment in the effort to hold AI companies accountable for the foreseeable harms caused by their products,” said Matt Bergman, founder of the Social Media Victims Law Center, who helped spearhead lawsuits against social media companies that relied on many of the same legal arguments Bonta is deploying against OpenAI. Bergman’s firm has also sued AI companies.
What harms? No human was hurt. There is that whole “rebuilding a third of their infrastructure” thing, but, Hugging Face isn’t complaining. So, why is the PRC going after OpenAI?
Jason Harrow, an attorney representing LASST, said the organization welcomes California’s suit.
“What’s different here is the legislature has said the attorney general has the responsibility to do this kind of stuff,” Thaw said. “It’s not some creative claim that pushes the boundaries of the attorney general’s authority – it’s literally following California laws” that authorize Bonta to investigate and seek to prosecute business practices that appear to be broadly harmful.
So, he’s following the overly expansive Nanny State laws of the PRC. But, on the other hand, OpenAI did allow it’s AI agents to go rogue, and, come on, they do not do that without poorly thought out programming. They are not sentient. And maybe the state does need to make an example of a company engaged in poor business practices
Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier has also filed a lawsuit against OpenAI under that state’s public nuisance and unfair trade practices laws, focused on AI chatbot output.
Politico threw that in there to make Bonta’s suit look better, so, maybe the PRC’s suit isn’t that good, because Florida’s is about “The state claims ChatGPT causes behavioral addiction, cognitive decline, and mental health risks, harvests minors’ data without proper parental oversight, and encourages self-harm or violence”, helped plan violent attacks, and “unfair trade practices, negligence, product liability violations, fraudulent misrepresentation, and public nuisance” (those came from Google AI putting together what the suit is about). So, maybe I’m against the PRC suit for overreach?
Read: PRC Sues OpenAI Over Hugging Face Hack »